Some believe throwing a steak on a grill, searing it and then immediately eating it will make for a good meal, I disagree. Because steak is one of the items I will pay a little extra, for good quality, I take particular steps to ensure I am getting the best flavor, juiciness and tenderness for my money. I will spend more for grain fed meat, when I can find it.
Chart courtesy of Omaha Steaks
Choose the right cut
Tenderloin – Known to be tender. Found on the back of the cow, has very little marbling (fat). Expensive compared to other cuts. Also known as the filet-Mignon.
Ribeye – Usually has the most marbling than other cuts. Found under the ribs, on the upper back of the cow. Known to be a very juicy, if cooked properly.
New York Strip – Is usually a larger cut of steak because it is cut from the short loin of the cow, lower back. Usually has very little fat content, can be tender but not as tender as the tenderloin.
T-Bone or Porterhouse – cut from the rear end of the short loin and thus include more tenderloin steak, along with (on the other side of the bone) a large strip steak.
Acclimate your steak
Opinions vary about whether or not to bring your steak to room temperature before cooking – I ALWAYS sit out a thawed steak on the counter approximately 20-30 minutes before cooking. You are doing this NOT to increase the internal temperature of the steak, but are doing it, so the surface of the steak becomes dry. Sprinkle salt on both sides of your steak when you sit it out to acclimate. The salt draws out liquid and then the liquid will be reabsorb, leaving a dry surface. Once on grill, the dry surface will brown and cause the interior to become more juicy.
Dry-aged steaks are so popular because a dry skin is forming on the steak, allowing it to brown in record time upon searing. The drier the meat is to start, the more moist it will be at the end.
Flavor with a rub?
There are many options on the market for “seasoning” a steak. Honestly, the best seasoning is salt and pepper. Using Kosher salt is the best option. The coarse crystals will really grab onto the meat.
Once the grill is hot, dip a small portion of paper towel in some good olive oil, then rub on the grill surface using some tongs. Not only will this help prevent the steak from sticking to the grill grate, but also will provide some flavor to the meat as well. Also, you may want to brush some melted butter onto the steak’s surface before searing. Just do not apply oil or butter to heavy, as it could start a fire in the grill.
Time to Grill
The key to a perfect steak is cooking it at a high temperature for a short amount of time. The colder the steak is when it hits the grill, the longer it will take to cook it. And the more time it spends over the heat, the tougher it gets.
Click the image to buy your own Thermopen.
Use a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature of the steak.
This will ensure a properly cooked steak, instead of relying on the poking or prodding method.
I disagree with some that say, to only flip your steak once during cooking.
In my experience, flipping the steak several times allows for a more evenly cooked steak and a better crust. However, I never mash the steak or cause the delicious juices to seep out of the meat.
Good rule of temperature is:
|Rare||120 to 125 degrees F
49 to 51 degrees C
|center is bright red, pinkish toward the exterior portion, and warm throughout|
|Medium Rare||130 to 135 degrees F
55 to 57 degrees C
|center is very pink, slightly brown toward the exterior portion, and slightly hot|
|Medium||140 to 145 degrees F
60 to 63 degrees C
|center is light pink, outer portion is brown, and hot throughout|
|Medium Well||150 to 155 degrees F
65 to 69 degrees C
|mostly gray-brown throughout with a hint of pink in the center|
|Well Done||160 degrees F and above
71 degrees C
|uniformly brown or grey throughout|
How do you like your steak cooked? Rare, Medium, Medium Well or Well Done? Comment below!